An open letter to Justice Anil R Dave: On NEET 2016 you made a good order Sir! Just make it better
Updated on Apr 30, 2016 - 1:47 p.m. IST by Mahesh Sarma
#NEET
Applications Open Now
UPES School of Health Sciences
Apply
MANIPAL, MAHE Admissions 2020
Apply

Dear Justice Dave,

 

I edit Careers360, a magazine and portal that seeks to help students make better education and career choices by providing authentic information. We serve about 8-10 million children each month.

 

For the last three days since your historic order the phone lines in our counseling center has not stopped ringing. 100s of parents, children and their well-wishers are calling worried. Will the exam stand? Will  NEET 2 happen? Why can’t NEET 1 aspirants write NEET 2? What will happen to KEAM which has already been conducted? Questions fly thick and fast. We seek to reassure them despite the picture actually being murky. But one thing stands out in all the callers. They are fundamentally happy if there is a single test.  And they applaud you for taking a stand.

 

At the risk of sounding presumptuous let me remind you the thought you had in that dissenting judgment you gave in 2013 in page 186 “From and among those students, who have secured prescribed qualifying marks, the concerned institutions, who want to give priority to the students belonging to a particular class or caste or creed or religion or region, etc. would be in a position to give preference to such students in the matter of their admission to the concerned medical college. Thus, the purpose with which the Articles 25, 26, 29, and 30 are incorporated in our Constitution would be fully respected and implemented.”

 

A fascinating thought. I think it is this thought that I think led to the 28th April order. But Sir, I must acknowledge the issue of state govt’s conducting their own test, issues of multiple boards and their differential standards, and the reasonable arguments by states like Tamil Nadu who have banned entrance exams and admit students based on their performance in state board exams are not considered in depth in your judgment in 2013. Some of them are quite reasonable and I am hazarding a guess that you decided to hear issues of state level exams etc. on 3rd May stems from this acknowledgement.

 

But Hon’ Justice Dave please do not throw the baby with the bath water. Based on my interactions with children let me suggest some ways out to hold to the prime principle that governed your judgment and the overarching need to ensure that admission are fair, transparent and non- exploitative.

 

The crux of the objection to NEET is threefold:

 

a)      Many students might have not taken AIPMT seriously and put all their eggs on their state entrance/state board. And some might have opted for AIPMT on a lark.   This  is a fact. And they might be inconvenienced if AIPMT becomes NEET and decides their fate. They are not represented before your Hon Court sir at all. But this issue is real

 

b)      States like Tamil Nadu do not conduct entrance exams. Board marks decide students’ fate.   So in these states, I know lakhs of student who study up to 10th in CBSE boards, opt for easier state board at 12th to score better and get a course of their choice. And there is also an issue of rural students who study for the boards as if their life depends on it. They too exist. And I am sure Tamil Nadu counsel would ably argue that before you on Monday.

 

c)       You have demolished the arguments of institutions like CMC, Vellore /AIIMS that seek a separate entrance exam citing their uniqueness in your judgment. So, I am not interested in laboring that point again. But they would again  be at it on Monday or the next day of hearing

 

Here is probably a way out Justice Dave.

 

a)      Let AIPMT on 1st may continue to be NEET 1. Allow students who took AIPMT to appear for NEET 2 if they so wish.   

 

b)      Let the NEET 2 announced for July/August be open to everybody including those who take NEET 1.   All those students who seek admissions could prepare and give the test. They have time, and enough notice. And no surprises. Let CBSE prepare a merit list based on the best performance in either one AIPMT/NEET.  This way, students have nothing to complain.

 

c)       For this year allow individual states to either admit students based on marks in their board/ or NEET. Either the state must have enough faith on its own board so that scores in it must be sufficient enough to admit students in its colleges. Or it must go through a national test. This is a sub-optimal solution. But might serve the purpose of the state governments and remove their opposition temporarily.

 

d)      All other institutions whether it is AIIMS or JIPMER or CMC must either admit students through their respective state merit list or the NEET merit list. They could have their choice.

 

e)      Until we could have a common board throughout the country, it should either be one national entrance or one board performance. Either way it will be one TEST finally.

Sir, you and your bench made a good order. Please make it better. But do not allow the cacophony of multiple voices to drown out the fundamentals.

 

Regards

Mahesh Sarma

Editor, Careers360

 

Stay tuned to www.medicine.careers360 for more news and updates on AIPMT 2016

 

Read More:

Why NEET 2016 is a great move and why it may not last long? 

NEET to be implemented for 2016-17; AIPMT renamed as NEET 2016 - phase 1

CBSE announces dates for NEET 2016; May 1 AIPMT is now NEET phase 1

CBSE to conduct NEET for 2016-17 admission; SC asks for exam schedule on April 28

Supreme Court clears way for common medical entrance examination across India

 

Applications Open Now

NMIMS NPAT 2020
NMIMS NPAT 2020
Apply
UPES School of Health Sciences
UPES School of Health Sciences
Apply
MANIPAL, MAHE Admissions 2020
MANIPAL, MAHE Admissions 2020
Apply
Symbiosis Entrance Test (SET-2020)
Symbiosis Entrance Test (SET-...
Apply
View All Application Forms

More like NEET

Questions related to NEET

Showing 79746 out of 79746 Questions
4 Views

can anyone suggest me most important chapters in physics,chemistry ,biologyfor neet UG2020,please help me to prepare well thank you........

Devraj choudhary Student Expert 18th Feb, 2020

Hii

The question asked in NEET are not too tough, but one need to have enough practice to solve it. So  you can refer these books-

Chemistry- NCERT is enough

Physics- ncert as well as Hc verma

Biology- trumen or any other coaching material along with NCERT.

Hope it helps

8 Views

if chemistry became my 4th subject and my aggregate mark in pcb is 65 my I eligible for neet

Yastika Kumar 18th Feb, 2020

Hi Lakhyajyoti,

The NEET eligibility criteria states that the candidate must have passed 10+2 or equivalent from a recognised board with Physics, Chemistry, Biology/BioTechnology and English as core subjects.The qulaifying marks for PCB is 50%-UR, 40%-OBC/SC/ST, 45%-PWD. So yes you are eligible to appear for NEET.

For more Information please refer this link:

https://medicine.careers360.com/articles/neet-eligibility-criteria

5 Views

what is the fees of govt seat in private dental colleges of karnataka through neet?

Srijika Bhattacharyya 18th Feb, 2020
Hello,
All counselling of MBBS seats in private colleges is done by KEA depending on your NEET rank.
Fee structure for BDS is :
Government college- rs 49850
Government seat in private college- rs 84,935
Private seat- 5,45,268
Hope this has cleared your doubts .
Feel free to ask if you have any other queries.
All the best
19 Views

how to clear neet in first attempt?

Dhameer Bhatia Student Expert 18th Feb, 2020

Know the Neet syllabus & what’s important


Study all the chapters taught in class 11 and 12 thoroughly. 70 to 80 percent of the overall questions are either directly taken from NCERT or are an advanced form of its learnings. Before you take on the study effort, go through the previous years' papers, so much so that, you can identify the important topics and concepts. Study those thoroughly, and prioritize these topics before you move to the less important ones.


Make a study strategy


Ensure you make a good timetable that includes solving test papers, regular revisions, and small breaks to help you recuperate and start afresh. Strictly abide by it and allocate more time to difficult subjects. Make it a habit to cover difficult topics along with interesting ones so that preparation does not become monotonous. Keep a track of time as you do not want one chapter to consume time and affect your overall study plan.


Solve test papers


As soon as you complete your syllabus, start solving as many test papers as you can. As the final date approaches, solve 3-4 test papers/mocks tests a day. Try to complete the test papers within the designated time. Demarcate the questions where you made a mistake and identify its cause. Revise all the incorrectly attempted questions well. In this manner, you will be able to understand your weaknesses better and prepare strategically, which is very important for a competitive exam like NEET.


Revise well


Along with your mock test papers take some time out to revise lessons. This should begin after you have completed studying all the lessons. If you are facing difficulty in grasping a certain topic, formula, diagram, etc, prepare a learning aid (like flashcards) and fix it in front of your study table. Do not be overconfident about your preparation and pay attention to the technique applied to crack the question while you’re revising.


Develop your own study technique


Every student will have a different strategy to crack the exam. While preparing for a competitive exam like NEET, follow a study technique that helps you recall your lessons well and allows you to solve the paper in the stipulated time. Follow the one that suits you best and adhere to the pattern till the day of examination. Do not panic and alter your strategy a few days before the exam - this is likely to hamper your preparation and affect your confidence before the examination.

3 Views

What is acctual subject for NEET

Suryashis Chakraborty 18th Feb, 2020

Hello Kunal,

The NEET Exam is a pen paper based examination of 3 hours. The question paper comprises of questions from Physics, Chemistry and Biology (Zoology and Botany). The NEET syllabus is prepared on the basis of MCI notified common syllabus of the medical entrance exam. The examination serves as a gateway to the medical colleges of the country for medical aspirants.

NEET Physics Syllabus:

Class XI

Class XII

Physical world and measurement

Electrostatics

Kinematics

Current Electricity

Laws of Motion

Magnetic Effects of Current and Magnetism

Work, Energy and Power

Electromagnetic Induction and Alternating Currents

Motion of System of Particles and Rigid Body

Electromagnetic Waves

Gravitation

Optics

Properties of Bulk Matter

Dual Nature of Matter and Radiation

Thermodynamics , Oscillations and Waves

Atoms and Nuclei

Behaviour of Perfect Gas and Kinetic Theory

Electronic Devices


NEET Chemistry Syllabus:

Class XI

Class XII

Some Basic Concepts of Chemistry

Solid State

Structure of Atom

Solutions

Classification of Elements and Periodicity in Properties

Electrochemistry

Chemical Bonding and Molecular Structure

Chemical Kinetics

States of Matter: Gases and Liquids

Surface Chemistry

Thermodynamics

General Principles and Processes of Isolation of Elements

Equilibrium

p-Block Elements

Redox Reactions

d and f Block Elements

Hydrogen

Coordination Compounds

s-Block Element (Alkali and Alkaline earth metals)

Haloalkanes and Haloarenes

Some p-Block Elements

Alcohols, Phenols and Ethers

Organic Chemistry- Some Basic Principles and Techniques

Aldehydes, Ketones and Carboxylic Acids

Hydrocarbons

Organic Compounds Containing Nitrogen

Environmental Chemistry

Biomolecules , Polymers and Chemistry in Everyday Life


NEET Biology Syllabus:

Class XI

Class XII

Diversity in Living World

Reproduction

Structural Organization in Animals and Plants

Genetics and Evolution

Cell Structure and Function

Biology and Human Welfare

Plant Physiology

Biotechnology and Its Applications

Human Physiology

Ecology and Environment


Hope this helps you. We wish you the best for your future endeavours!

Regards




Top
The question have been saved in answer later, you can access it from your profile anytime. Access now

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

Careers360 App
150M+ Students
24,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books