An open letter to Justice Anil R Dave: On NEET 2016 you made a good order Sir! Just make it better
Mahesh Sarma, 30 Apr 2016, #NEET

Dear Justice Dave,

 

I edit Careers360, a magazine and portal that seeks to help students make better education and career choices by providing authentic information. We serve about 8-10 million children each month.

 

For the last three days since your historic order the phone lines in our counseling center has not stopped ringing. 100s of parents, children and their well-wishers are calling worried. Will the exam stand? Will  NEET 2 happen? Why can’t NEET 1 aspirants write NEET 2? What will happen to KEAM which has already been conducted? Questions fly thick and fast. We seek to reassure them despite the picture actually being murky. But one thing stands out in all the callers. They are fundamentally happy if there is a single test.  And they applaud you for taking a stand.

 

At the risk of sounding presumptuous let me remind you the thought you had in that dissenting judgment you gave in 2013 in page 186 “From and among those students, who have secured prescribed qualifying marks, the concerned institutions, who want to give priority to the students belonging to a particular class or caste or creed or religion or region, etc. would be in a position to give preference to such students in the matter of their admission to the concerned medical college. Thus, the purpose with which the Articles 25, 26, 29, and 30 are incorporated in our Constitution would be fully respected and implemented.”

 

A fascinating thought. I think it is this thought that I think led to the 28th April order. But Sir, I must acknowledge the issue of state govt’s conducting their own test, issues of multiple boards and their differential standards, and the reasonable arguments by states like Tamil Nadu who have banned entrance exams and admit students based on their performance in state board exams are not considered in depth in your judgment in 2013. Some of them are quite reasonable and I am hazarding a guess that you decided to hear issues of state level exams etc. on 3rd May stems from this acknowledgement.

 

But Hon’ Justice Dave please do not throw the baby with the bath water. Based on my interactions with children let me suggest some ways out to hold to the prime principle that governed your judgment and the overarching need to ensure that admission are fair, transparent and non- exploitative.

 

The crux of the objection to NEET is threefold:

 

a)      Many students might have not taken AIPMT seriously and put all their eggs on their state entrance/state board. And some might have opted for AIPMT on a lark.   This  is a fact. And they might be inconvenienced if AIPMT becomes NEET and decides their fate. They are not represented before your Hon Court sir at all. But this issue is real

 

b)      States like Tamil Nadu do not conduct entrance exams. Board marks decide students’ fate.   So in these states, I know lakhs of student who study up to 10th in CBSE boards, opt for easier state board at 12th to score better and get a course of their choice. And there is also an issue of rural students who study for the boards as if their life depends on it. They too exist. And I am sure Tamil Nadu counsel would ably argue that before you on Monday.

 

c)       You have demolished the arguments of institutions like CMC, Vellore /AIIMS that seek a separate entrance exam citing their uniqueness in your judgment. So, I am not interested in laboring that point again. But they would again  be at it on Monday or the next day of hearing

 

Here is probably a way out Justice Dave.

 

a)      Let AIPMT on 1st may continue to be NEET 1. Allow students who took AIPMT to appear for NEET 2 if they so wish.   

 

b)      Let the NEET 2 announced for July/August be open to everybody including those who take NEET 1.   All those students who seek admissions could prepare and give the test. They have time, and enough notice. And no surprises. Let CBSE prepare a merit list based on the best performance in either one AIPMT/NEET.  This way, students have nothing to complain.

 

c)       For this year allow individual states to either admit students based on marks in their board/ or NEET. Either the state must have enough faith on its own board so that scores in it must be sufficient enough to admit students in its colleges. Or it must go through a national test. This is a sub-optimal solution. But might serve the purpose of the state governments and remove their opposition temporarily.

 

d)      All other institutions whether it is AIIMS or JIPMER or CMC must either admit students through their respective state merit list or the NEET merit list. They could have their choice.

 

e)      Until we could have a common board throughout the country, it should either be one national entrance or one board performance. Either way it will be one TEST finally.

Sir, you and your bench made a good order. Please make it better. But do not allow the cacophony of multiple voices to drown out the fundamentals.

 

Regards

Mahesh Sarma

Editor, Careers360

 

Stay tuned to www.medicine.careers360 for more news and updates on AIPMT 2016

 

Read More:

Why NEET 2016 is a great move and why it may not last long? 

NEET to be implemented for 2016-17; AIPMT renamed as NEET 2016 - phase 1

CBSE announces dates for NEET 2016; May 1 AIPMT is now NEET phase 1

CBSE to conduct NEET for 2016-17 admission; SC asks for exam schedule on April 28

Supreme Court clears way for common medical entrance examination across India

 

MBBS Companion 2019

Predict chances in 3000+ colleges, Know All India Counselling & Admission process etc.

Know More

Admissions Open Now

Manav Rachna International Ins..
Apply
Symbiosis Institute of Busines..
Apply
Banasthali Vidyapith, Banastha..
Apply
Symbiosis Entrance Test SET 20..
Apply
BITSAT 2019
Apply
NMIMS Admissions 2019
Apply
Manipal Academy of Higher Educ..
Apply
View All Application Forms

More like NEET

Questions related to NEET

Is NEET is needed for m.s in general surgery

5 Minutes ago

MS is a Post-Graduate degree in general surgery requires qualification in NEET PG Entrance Examination. To be eligible for NEET PG, you must have a...

My state domicile is Tripura . If I chose my neet exam centre in a state other then Tripura will my state domicile get cancelled?

5 Hours ago

Dear Shuvo, your domicile depends on various factors like the years you spent either studying in a certain state or residing in another State. It h...

Name the best medical college or deemed universityin India which are accepting 300above marks for general category in neet in mbbs

8 Hours ago

For best medical colleges in the country you need to be in the top 200, and the corresponding marks shall be greater than 650+.Some of them are MAM...

Hello sir/mam I got BAMS seat in 2018 NEET process but am not admissioned , am I eligible 2019 BAMS course Thank you,

5 Hours ago

Dear Krishna, if your question is if you can appear for NEET for BAMS course in 2019 again though you got a seat and never joined college, yes you ...

I have prepared much good for neet but now I am unable to concentrate.My mind just think random stuff which are useless.What to do now?

10 Hours ago

I would suggest you to meditate (you may take help of Headspace App if you have Android device). And also sleep for a minimum of 7-8 hours everyday...

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

Careers360 App
150M+ Students
24,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books