NEET 2017: How will the SC verdict on age limit impact aspirants?
None, 01 Mar 2017, #NEET

The National Eligibility cum Entrance Test’s (NEET) 2017 journey has traversed a tumultuous path ever since the CBSE issued its controversial eligibility notification on January 31 this year. The notification, which introduced unexpected changes to the NEET 2017 rules including caps on the number of attempts and a new upper age limit of 25 years (30 years for reserved candidates) disqualified thousands of MBBS/BDS aspirants in one stroke. Following the removal on the number of attempts after massive protests across the country, students are now hopeful that the age limit ruling will also be scrapped. The matter is currently pending in the Supreme Court, with the final verdict expected to be pronounced on March 20.

Also Read -
NEET 2018
NEET Eligibility Criteria 2018
NEET Important Dates 2018

Latest :  Crack NEET 2020 with NEET Knockout Program( AI-Based Coaching), If you Do Not Qualify- Get 100% MONEY BACK. Know More

 

The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court is also currently hearing a similar petition challenging the introduction of the upper age limit in NEET 2017. The Allahabad High Court’s verdict, which was expected to be declared on February 28, has also now been adjourned to March 20 and will be released in accordance with the Supreme Court’s decision.

NEET Online Preparation

Crack NEET 2020 with NEET Knockout Program, If you Do Not Qualify- Get 100% MONEY BACK

Start Now

 

Given that the SC and the Allahabad HC have issued similar directives to the MCI to clarify how the NEET upper age limit criteria has been determined, and whether it has followed the correct procedure, the observations made by the High Court as well as the Apex Court will be useful to gauge in whose favour the final judgment may be.

 

Keeping the interests of students in mind, Careers360 provides a background of the case so far and also assesses the possible outcomes that may be realized once the Supreme Court’s verdict is declared.

 

Scenario 1: Upper Age Limit Stays

 

If the MCI and the CBSE are able to persuade the Supreme Court in their final arguments that introducing the upper age limit is a good move, thousands of NEET UG applicants who have crossed the age of 25 (30 in the case of reserved categories) will not be able to write the exam nor be eligible for admissions to any medical college in the country.

 

MCI arguments thus far

The MCI’s arguments until now have attempted to reinforce its stance that upper age candidates could use unfair means to qualify for the exam. “Capping the upper age limit at 25 years gives a reasonable span of 8 years to a candidate to appear in NEET. The provision of absence of upper age limit is misused by unscrupulous elements, impersonators and candidates belonging to higher age groups (apparently doctors, teachers, coaching personal etc)...”, the MCI affidavit had stated. The MCI cited the case of age limits being present for other national level exams such as JEE (Advanced) for admissions to IITs and CLAT for National Law Schools, thus justifying its introduction in NEET.

 

The MCI also argued before the Supreme Court that age was a major factor in the practice of medicine and that “sharp young minds” were required to absorb the rigorous training imparted in MBBS and BDS courses.

 

In response to queries of the Supreme Court and the Allahabad High Court regarding the legitimacy of the new rules, the MCI in its response to the latter on February 23 stated that the Council’s Executive Committee had introduced the age limit via a resolution, and this had been subsequently passed by the Government of India, thus indicating a proper exercise of power which made the rule legitimate.

 

In response to the Supreme Court’s query as to whether there existed any provision for upper age limit in the existing NEET Acts or whether any such amendment had been lawfully introduced, the MCI replied that while such a provision did not exist in any of the Acts or Laws, it was in the process of being introduced.

 

If the Courts are convinced

On March 20, the Supreme Court will hear further arguments from the MCI’s side about how they intend to fix the age limit despite the absence of formal regulations to that effect so far. The Allahabad High Court is expected to pronounce its verdict in accordance with the SC’s decision on the same date. If the procedure is found satisfactory by the Court, along with the MCI’s argument that younger candidates will be at a disadvantage if there is no upper age cap, the age limit criteria for NEET 2017 will remain in force and students above the age of 25 (30 for SC/ST) will be disqualified from pursuing MBBS/BDS courses in the country.

 

Scenario 2: Upper Age Limit is Revoked

 

By assessing the statements and observations made by the Supreme Court and the Allahabad High Court thus far, there remains a strong possibility that the NEET upper age limit criteria could be scrapped atleast for this year. The main contention of the petitioners at the Supreme Court and the Allahabad High Court is that the new criteria of upper age limit of 25 years is not supported by any appropriate regulation or procedure prescribed by the regulations framed under the Medical Council of India Act. As its introduction has not been in conformity with law, it deserves to be struck down, the petitioners argue.

 

Observations of the Allahabad HC

While the MCI had replied that the introduction of the rule had been as per the proper procedure, the Allahabad High Court had observed that the MCI’s arguments on introducing the upper age limit were not very convincing.

 

“We have perused the said documents and we find that the exercise does not appear to have been taken to amend the 1997 Regulations by introducing any prescription of the upper age limit...In our opinion the field was already occupied by the Regulations and, therefore, the Medical Council of India could have framed the Regulations 1997 and got it approved by the Central Government. This exercise does not appear to have been undertaken and the power to frame Regulations in Section 33 of the Act does not appear to have been invoked by the competent authority,” the two member bench comprising Justices Amreshwar Pratap Sahi and Sanjay Harkauli had stated on February 23.

 

The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court, which was expected to give its verdict on February 27 in line with the Supreme Court's decision, has also adjourned its verdict to March 20. On Tuesday, February 28, the Allahabad High Court, after being informed about the Supreme Court's adjournment, stated, "It is...informed at the Bar that the matter was taken up yesterday and the Apex Court has been pleased to fix 20.3.2017 in the matter..Let the matters come up on 20.3.2017...In the event any orders are passed by the Apex Court, the same shall be brought to the notice of this Court as well."

 

Observations of the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court, while hearing the MCI’s response on February 27, queried as to whether there existed any provision for upper age limit in the existing Acts governing NEET or whether any such amendment had been appropriately introduced. The MCI replied to the Bench that while they did not have any such provision currently, they were in the process of introducing it. The MCI also informed the Court that it had introduced the upper age limit based on the CBSE’s guidance. In response, while adjourning the matter to March 20, the Court had remarked that the MCI and other respondents needed to show substantial reasons and evidences in favor of their decision in the next hearing. Given that the last date for NEET application submissions was March 1, the Supreme Court also stated that if at all the verdict were to be in favour of the petitioners, the CBSE would have to reopen its online application interface window for the candidates who could not apply earlier due to the upper age limit rule.

 

If the Supreme Court does pass its verdict in favor of the petitioners on March 20, all the candidates above the age of 25 who had applied to NEET 2017 would become eligible to appear for the exam. There might be a chance that this ruling will only be applicable for NEET 2017 only and the age limit might be reintroduced for NEET 2018. But atleast it will mean that the thousands of students who were denied at the last moment after preparing for NEET 2017 for so long will be able to appear for the exam this year and not have their time and efforts wasted.

UPDATE FROM SC ORDER: As per the SC order released on February 27, if the petitioners challenging the age limit succeed, the NEET application window will be reopened. However, relief will not be granted to any petitioner who hasn't approached the SC or HC before the NEET application form last date. "In case the petitioners succeed, the time for filling up the forms shall be extended. Needless to say, a person who has not approached either the High Court or this Court prior to expiry of the date cannot get the benefit of the order of this Court.", the order reads. It remains to be seen if the NEET 2017 age limit is removed on March 20, and if so, what the recourse for over-age candidates who did not or could not approach the Courts will be. 

 

Stay tuned to www.medicine.careers360.com for more information on NEET

Applications Open Now

UPES - School of Health Sciences
UPES - School of Health Sciences
Apply
MyNEET 2020- Mock Test
MyNEET 2020- Mock Test
Apply
View All Application Forms

More like NEET

Questions related to NEET

Showing 76801 out of 76804 Questions
1 View

sir I belongs to obc category but applied UR in neet application is their any problem regarding this

Priyaanka Sarkar Student Expert 6th Dec, 2019

Bhagya, if you fall in the Creamy Layer of OBC, then you have to select your Category as General Category while filling in the application form. But if you fall under Non creamy layer you have to select OBC. Now even if you belong to OBC-NCL but want to opt out of reservation, you can select General Category. But if you belong to OBC-NCL and you want to claim your reservation, you can change your Category during the correction window when it opens in January 2020.

7 Views

what are the documents to apply neet exam?

Halry Bhalodia 6th Dec, 2019

Important Documents Required for NEET 2020

  • The scanned copy of your recent photograph. It should be in JPG format and file size must be between 10KB and 100KB. Make sure that the photograph is taken with a white background and the candidate’s name and date of photo taken must be mentioned at the bottom of the Photograph.
  • The scanned copy of your signature. It should be in JPG format and file size must be between 3KB and 20KB.
  • Requirement for Aadhaar for the NEET Applicants 2020 –

    The aadhaar card is not mandatory for the NEET exam 2020.

    Additional Tips to Keep in Mind While Filling NEET 2020 Application Form –

  • Using prefixes in the name of Mother or Father is not allowed.
  • Name, date of birth, gender must be as per Aadhaar card or correction request.
  • Mobile number and email address must be provided when asked.
  • Remember to note down the registration number for future correspondence.
  • Make sure to keep your debit/ credit card or net banking credential ready to make the payment of fees.
  • Keep a copy of the fee payment and confirmation page safe for future correspondence.
6 Views

What is the upper age limit to appear in neet 2020 for OBC candidate?

IMran Mir 6th Dec, 2019

Hi there Rousan!

Hope you are having a nice day!

I would like to inform you that the candidates who are 17 years and above as on the date of admissions or by December 31, 2020 are eligible to apply for NEET. There is no upper age limit as of now in NEET 2020. For more further details regarding age relaxation or reservation for NEET 2020, I am giving you a link below:-

https://medicine.careers360.com/exams/neet

So use this link for all the information regarding NEET 2020 and I hope it will help you alot. All the best for your upcoming future.

Thanks

5 Views

i have cleared my 12th in 2019 but i didnt appeared in neet 2019 ...which code should i opt in 2020 neet application form?

Aditya kumar Student Expert 6th Dec, 2019
Hello !

You should choose code 02 dear as the code 02 is for those who have qualified Class 12 in the year 2019 or before and have not pursued any other course after the completion of Class 12 . So you need to select code 02.

Steps you need to follow for filling neet application form are listed below "-

  • Registration
  • Filling in the application of NEET 2020
  • Uploading of scanned images
  • NEET application fee payment
  • Printing of confirmation page.

Also you need to upload following documents for filling neet application form :-

  • Your passport size photograph:- background should be white , preferably with name and date of taking the photograph. Photograph should not be with cap or goggles. The focus needs to be on face (80% face coverage, ears clearly visible, on white background).

  • Postcard size picture:- Must be taken on or after September 1, 2019.Preferably with name and date of taking the photograph and should not be with cap or goggles.

  • Signature:- it should be on white Background with black pen; signature should be in running hand writing [not in capital letter].

  • Left-hand thumb impression:- it should be with blue ink on white paper

  • Class 10 passing certificate :- You should scan your Class X Passing Certificate for uploading

For detailed information go through our page for which link is provided below :-

https://medicine.careers360.com/articles/neet-eligibility-criteria

Thankyou
8 Views

what size of photos should be taken to apply for neet application?

Bhaskar Nakkina Student Expert 6th Dec, 2019

Hii,

NEET is a National level Common Entrance test. While filling the NEET Application form, the photograph should be 20 to 200 KB of Size and the format should be JPG/JPEG only. The photograph should be clear and your face should be 80% covered and avoid using taking photo on Mobile.


Top
The question have been saved in answer later, you can access it from your profile anytime. Access now

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

Careers360 App
150M+ Students
24,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books