NEET 2017: Madras HC issues notice to CBSE, Centre on question paper controversy

NEET 2017: Madras HC issues notice to CBSEAmid demands for cancellation of NEET held on May 7, the Madras High Court has sought responses from the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) and the Union Health Secretary on controversies surrounding the question paper of the national level MBBS/BDS entrance exam. An official notice has been issued in this regard by the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court, where nine medical students filed a Writ Petition demanding for the exam to be canceled. According to them, the official question papers released by the CBSE show varied questions in different languages. They want a exam to be conducted with a translation of the same question paper being used in all languages. “One India, one question paper in NEET is a must, otherwise the method of assessing intelligence and aptitude would differ...NEET examination should be cancelled and fresh examination with uniform question papers (should) be conducted,” the Madurai petitioners, all of whom appeared for the exam in English, were quoted as saying to media sources.

 

NEET UG Pathfinder
Know your NEET UG expected rank now!

Responding to the petition, Justice N Seshasayee asked the Centre and the CBSE to reply to the allegations within one week. However, the judge refused to pass any order at this stage regarding the students’ request for an interim injunction that would restrict the Directorate General for Health Services (DGHS) and state governments from proceeding with medical admissions this year on the basis of NEET scores.

Admissions Open Now
Admissions 2018 open at Banasthali Vidyapith|NAAC A Grade| QS 4 Star| Apply

 

Held on May 7, the National Eligibility cum Entrance Examination (NEET) 2017 has found itself surrounded by numerous controversies over the past few weeks. From allegations of paper leaks to complaints against the aggressive frisking of candidates at certain exam centres, protests against various issues associated with the All India common medical entrance exam have seen students, parents and education activists come together in various parts of the country.

 

None of the issues however, have united them to the extent that the claim raised by students from various states about the NEET Question Paper being different in different languages has. While the established practise with regard to holding any exam in different languages is to translate the questions and keep everything else the same for the purposes of standardization, this was apparently not the case for NEET 2017, despite a uniform syllabus being announced.

 

Ever since students from West Bengal, Maharashtra and Gujarat pointed out that they had received different question papers which were more difficult in nature and not even based on the same pattern as the English and Hindi ones, demands have been rising on social media and other platforms for a NEET 2017 re-exam. Infact, following the controversy in Telangana where students were forced to appear for NEET in English and Hindi despite having opted for Telugu, the CBSE organized a re-exam for the 230 affected candidates in their preferred language on May 17. This may have encouraged the protesting candidates in other states to believe that the CBSE will be receptive to their demands for a re-exam, especially given that HRD Minister Prakash Javadekar also assured them that a clarification will soon be issued regarding the languages controversy.

 

The students battling the case in Madurai may have to wait and see whether the CBSE indeed comes up with a satisfactory response or even acknowledges their claim that NEET was indeed different in different languages, thereby rendering it unfair and raising prospects of a re-test.

NEET 2017 will provide admissions to around 90,000 Medical and BDS seats in all Government, Private and Deemed medical educational institutions across India. Held in offline mode in 104 cities across the country, the exam was attended by more than 11 lakh candidates. Also, for the first ever time, the exam was held in English, Hindi and eight other regional languages, a decision which in hindsight could have been executed much better.

 

Visit medicine.careers360.com for more articles and updates on NEET!


Get real-time alerts on exam & colleges at your fingertips with Careers360 App!

Click Here to Install or Give a missed call on 08080944727 to get app link.

Related News

Suggested Reading: NEET|NEET News

QNA - EXAM QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

NEET UG

Join this QNA topic to get updates about latest happenings about the exam!

  • 23733 Joined
  • 14499 Questions
S

ss exports 11 minutes ago

ss exportss picture
Ss ExportsLast Seen: 11 min 20 sec agoJoined on: 20-May-2018Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: In Graduation

Neet score 385.sc categary .get tamil nadu govt medical college.

Answer (1)

User Pic
chandrashekhar rais picture
Chandrashekhar RaiLast Seen: 1 min 20 sec agoJoined on: 31-May-2016Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: In Graduation
Hey,
I am sorry but the score is quite low for you to get admission in government medical college!
S

sourjya 3 hours ago

sourjyas picture
SourjyaLast Seen: 2 hours 20 min agoJoined on: 25-May-2018Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: Class 12

My neet 2018 score is 639.what rank can i expect to get please?

Answer (1)

User Pic

harsh 24 minutes ago

harsh s picture
Harsh Last Seen: 17 min 57 sec agoJoined on: 18-Nov-2014Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: Class 12
Please use carreer360 rank predictor for having the idea of rank.
S

sourjya 3 hours ago

sourjyas picture
SourjyaLast Seen: 2 hours 20 min agoJoined on: 25-May-2018Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: Class 12

My neet 2018 score is 639.whats the chances of mine in getting into any medicall college in delhi?

will i get admission in GRANT Medical college ,mumbai yah seth GS medical college ,mumbai?

Answer (1)

P

PIYUSH MISHRA 3 hours ago

PIYUSH MISHRAs picture
PIYUSH MISHRALast Seen: 14 min 51 sec agoJoined on: 27-May-2018Education Interest: Study AbroadEducation Level: Graduate & Above
FOR SURE YOU WILL GET A GOVT MEDICAL COLLEGE

THANK  YOU

PIYUSH MISHRA
User Pic
preeti Katroliyas picture
Preeti KatroliyaLast Seen: 2 hours 24 min agoJoined on: 27-May-2018Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: Class 12

I m scoring 416 marks in neet 2018 I m from SC category can I have chances to get government college in madhya Pradesh or india

Answer (1)

User Pic

harsh 21 minutes ago

harsh s picture
Harsh Last Seen: 17 min 57 sec agoJoined on: 18-Nov-2014Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: Class 12
Yes you have chances of getting a college in madhya Pradesh at this score but if you have the state quota for mp then it will increase your chances.
Best of luck
User Pic

anchal sethi 4 hours ago

anchal sethis picture
Anchal SethiLast Seen: 3 hours 55 min agoJoined on: 12-Aug-2015Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: Class 12

I am a sc candidate and i am getting 420 in neet 2018 . Do I have any chances of getting into any govt. medical college in odisha?

I am a sc candidate and i am getting 420 in neet 2018 . Do I have any chances of getting into any govt. medical college in odisha under stat

Answer (1)

K

Kajol 2 hours ago

Kajols picture
KajolLast Seen: 1 hour 59 min agoJoined on: 17-May-2018Education Interest: MedicineEducation Level: In Graduation
Hello anchal The marks range for SC candidates in Odisha was 468-352 for 85% state quota seats. So according to this criteria you have fair enough chances of getting a govt medical college in odisha. ...Read More